5

The show requires us to suspend disbelief to the point where Roy Mustang can alter densities of gases or induce some chemical reactions, but not necessarily change elements themselves. It argues the energy required to generate 'real' transmutations is much higher, so you need something like the philosophers stone.

Now, the animes claim he generates explosions by altering oxygen density profiles in the air and triggering a reaction by creating a spark. See under 'Abilities' here: http://fullmetal-alchemist-database.wikia.com/wiki/Roy_Mustang

However, while oxygen assists combustion, it is not flammable by itself. Hence, the flame needs to travel along a path of oxygen and combustible material from Mustang to his target. The show offers no explanation for where this combustible material comes from.

Perhaps flammable gases or water vapor (that could be converted to hydrogen) in air could be utilized to create explosions. However, these gases are present at levels lower than 1% in the atmosphere, and concentrating them sufficiently to create an explosive needs volumes several orders of magnitude larger than what Mustang has access to in the show. (intuitively, the atmospheric water vapor in the volume contained by a large living room will not fill a glass of water).

Given what I have argued so far, and without having to suspend disbelief further, how does Mustang's flame alchemy even work? It feels like the authors of the show are (erroneously) assuming oxygen is combustible.

user1992705
  • 153
  • 1
  • 5
  • 2
    Related/dupe: [How can Colonel Mustang create his flame alchemy differently?](https://anime.stackexchange.com/q/7793) – Aki Tanaka Sep 12 '17 at 20:34
  • Well, if you want to get into nuclear stuff, you could I guess break apart the nitrogen in the air and create hydrogen and blow that up. Or do something similar and create methane. – Becuzz Sep 13 '17 at 13:34
  • @Becuzz : Alchemy appears to be restricted to altering chemical bonds and structure; altering nuclear bonds may require much more energy than what a single alchemist can harness on his own. Given how characters express astonishment at flowers appearing from air or the formation of a mini sun, I don't think it is possible to turn nitrogen into hydrogen in the FMA world without a philosopher's stone or some large energy source. – user1992705 Sep 14 '17 at 18:36
  • 1
    @CloseVoters: This is not a dupe. This questions asks how does Flame alchemy work while the other stems from confusion about Circleless transmutation. – kaine Sep 14 '17 at 19:34
  • @user1992705 I don't really agree with that. There are many times where materials seem to change from one thing to another. Think of how many times Major Armstrong punched a rock and turned it into a metal arrow head thing. I doubt there was that much metal in a typical rock / piece of earth to make something that substantial. Second, the original goal of alchemy was to turn anything to gold, which given our current knowledge of chemistry would involve nuclear changes. Third, nuclear reactions can create an incredible amount of energy. Why couldn't an alchemist use that energy? – Becuzz Sep 14 '17 at 20:01
  • @Becuzz that should be a new question and is an interesting.one (Idk if it has been asked before). To my eyes, Armstrong's arrowheads look like stone. – kaine Sep 14 '17 at 20:44
  • @Becuzz Armstrong's arrows look like stone to me too. Also, it takes an extraordinary amount of energy to convert Pb to Au -- it's implied an alchemist would need a philosophers stone to carry out nuclear reactions like that. Initiating a fission reaction is non-trivial. As for why alchemists can't use fission energy if a reaction is initiated, I'd assume it's the same reason they can't use sunlight, electricity, etc. -- they don't posses the necessary transduction mechanism. The alchemists in the anime are shown to magically transduce energy from tectonic plate shifts, 'chi', or human souls. – user1992705 Sep 15 '17 at 01:27
  • @Becuzz Just to clarify, I am not saying nuclear reactions are impossible in the world of FMA. They just seem to be very difficult to carry out without a philosophers stone, which is why I am wondering if there is a non-nuclear explanation to how Mustang's flame alchemy works. I like the thought experiments that may arise in association with your question on why alchemists can't use other forms of energy -- maybe you ask it here. – user1992705 Sep 15 '17 at 01:32
  • Been awhile, but didn't Edward copy Greed's ability and convert at least the outer part of his automail to Greed's carbon based armor? I seem to remember he fought Pride with it. How would he do that without transmutation? Where did he get the carbon? From his body? A – HyperNym Apr 10 '21 at 04:53
  • Also, wasn't it explicitly stated that production of gold and silver money with Alchemy was illegal, since it could destroy a nation's economy? How could that be done without elemental transmutation? – HyperNym Apr 10 '21 at 05:01

1 Answers1

5

All we know about how Flame alchemy works is described in the question. As you note the description is incomplete.

That being said, we do know that creating flames in this way is a very complicated process and is a closely guarded secret. This secret was tattooed on the Hawkeye's back by its creator and entrusted by Hawkeye only to Mustang. A full explanation in-universe would, therefore, not make much sense.

We might never know what the exact mechanism is and it is not necessary to understand the story.

I can come up with several head-canons to justify this physics:

  • The mechanism does not necessarily involve chemistry. The Crimson Alchemist creates explosions by combining contradictory alchemical symbols.
  • An unstable explosive such as tetranitromethane or nitroglycerin could be formed in gaseous state.
  • My preferred one is for Mustang to produce large quantities of nitric oxide (NO). There is a slow reaction where 2NO -> N2 + O2 which is exothermic but NO is considered non-flammable. This is because the reaction is slow without a catalyst because the NO molecules have to collide to react. At very high concentrations with other chemicals, a spark, and magic (alchemy), I like to imagine Mustang can induce a suitable violent reaction which I couldn't get to working in a lab. The actual difficulty is finding a high heat of formation molecule containing only N, O, and C stable enough to disperse harmlessly without decomposing if he can't ignite it. Several such compounds probably exist but it isn't necessarily something that if familiar or can even has been synthesized in the real world. I suspect NO is too stable but is a starting point. NO (nitric oxide) explosions have been observed and require a spark to get started but also require some other fuel to be present.

Further speculation would constitute a fan theory so would be off topic on this site. I hope, however, this is enough to show you that an explanation is conceptually possible if not available (or possibly even known by the creator).

kaine
  • 5,244
  • 3
  • 26
  • 39
  • I agree that the mechanistic details are not necessary to the actual story. – user1992705 Sep 15 '17 at 01:38
  • Good answer. True, in the FMA universe, flame alchemy is very complicated (though we do not know what part of it is complicated: controlling gases, creating fuel, etc.?) I was wondering if our knowledge of chemical kinetics (without having to invoke nuclear reactions) alone could somehow account for Mustang's ability to generate bombs, and that does not seem to be the case. Fwiw, with every additional explanation I read or watch about flame alchemy, I am more convinced the author(s) assumed highly concentrated oxygen can somehow explode into flames. – user1992705 Sep 15 '17 at 02:00