8

In Koe no Katachi (A Silent Voice) my current interpretation of the X on someone's face is that the protagonist does not wish to acknowledge or socialize with this person. An extension of this could be perhaps that he does not wish to hear their "voice", if we were to stretch somewhat on the themes of the story.

Ueno is the only person I can think of when in the reconciliation phase gets the X on and off. I can understand it being a part of the protagonist's difficulty in attempting to reconcile with her and understand her motives (which interestingly play similarly to his own of attempting to reconcile Shoko with her classmates while she tries to reconcile him with his).

Wikipedia suggests it is his disgust for her.

I'm looking for any other interpretation preferably with evidence of when the X comes on and off. Is there a concrete pattern behind why and when the X is put on a person?

If I have time and can find the images I'll add a few with chapter references to better show examples of what I mean.

Gao
  • 9,603
  • 8
  • 57
  • 96
user1821961
  • 975
  • 3
  • 13
  • 24
  • the manga ver or the anime ? – Gagantous Sep 11 '17 at 12:46
  • manga preferably – user1821961 Sep 12 '17 at 01:09
  • The movie has far more to talk about in terms of the X's, the manga does have a handful of scenes exhibiting this, but the movie completely ran with it to the point where it became a central plot point... for other people reading answers perhaps try to include both – Jesse Dec 07 '17 at 01:30

1 Answers1

3

Spoiler Warning

.TL;DR

So the summary of this answer is:

  1. The "X" mark can be symbolized as "Not My Friend" or "No interest to interact with them". When Ishida feels pissed off because of an act or the attitude of someone/something, the "X" mark would be put on their faces. And when would the "X" mark be taken down? When Ishida thinks like "I like him/her, such a nice person" about someone or something.

  2. Because Ueno is so hypocritical, that make Ishida so pissed and happy at the same time. The X mark on Ueno's face was first marked in volume 3, and it came off in Volume 7 (the last volume), when Ishida tried to change himself. In volume 7, all the 'X' marks that everyone had in Ishida's perspective have already come off

The content from this point on contains spoilers. Read it at your own risk.

From what I could figure, the most accepted answer for this kind of question is one where you can find in the manga version. Although I have not watched the anime in full, the anime version seems lacking in explanation. And of course I have finished the manga.

1. What is the significance of the X on people's faces from Ishida's perspective?

The X's first appeared in Volume 1, Chapter 5, page 2-6. Here are some of the pages (read from right to left)

Page 2-3

enter image description here

Page 4-5

enter image description here

Page 6

enter image description here

He has an

anxiety disorder being with other people. He feels pissed off because of his own negative thought about the others. Look at the yellow marker, he hates everything, even the friend of friends that he hated. The "X" mark can be symbolized as "Not My Friend" or "No interest to interact with them". So that's the reason why the entire class have "X" mark on their faces. For Nagatsuka why he got "X" mark from the first, there is something that Ishida hates about him. For the other people like Sahara that doesn't have "X" mark when they met on the train, because Ishida has no reason to hate Sahara for some reason (exclude his classmate nor neighborhood that he hate). He will put the "X" mark down when someone wants to acknowledge him more and he trusted it.

2. Why does Ueno get the X on and off?

It's explained in Volume 3, Chapter 18, Page 12-17 (read from right to left).

Page 12-13

enter image description here

Page 14-15

enter image description here

Page 16-17

enter image description here

Ishida said that he doesn't care about his ex-friend (aka all his elementary school friends) in pages 12-13, but when he met Ueno for the first time since junior high school, he did care. At first, Ueno's face didn't have the "X" mark but in chapter 21, pages 9-10, Ueno did something terrible to Shouko, and that made Ishida really pissed of with Ueno's attitude. So that's why Ueno got the 'X' mark on pages 15-16.

Page 9-10

enter image description here

Page 15-16

enter image description here

Community
  • 1
Gagantous
  • 3,260
  • 19
  • 46
  • 91